Plans to build a 20-metre mobile phone mast on Queen Elizabeth Way in Kirk Hallam have been refused by Erewash Borough Council following strong local opposition and concerns over its impact on the area’s character.
The proposal, submitted by telecommunications operator Alan Osborne, sought permission for a 20-metre steel pole fitted with nine antennas, two dishes and two ground-level equipment cabinets. The mast was to be located on a raised section of land beside the pavement, directly opposite residential homes and near open green space.
After assessing the application, planning officers used delegated powers to reject the plan, describing it as an “incongruous intrusion” that would harm the look and feel of the neighbourhood. The refusal notice stated that the mast’s industrial design, height and position would have a “substantial detrimental visual impact” on the surrounding area.
Residents who commented on the proposal raised concerns about the mast’s visual impact, potential disruption during construction, and lack of consultation. Some also questioned whether alternative sites had been properly explored.
In its detailed report, the council noted that several other locations considered by the developer — including Deepdale Avenue and near the Asda Express on Ladywood Road — would have been more suitable and less intrusive. Planning officers concluded that the applicant had not justified why those sites were ruled out.
Although national planning policy encourages councils to support improvements to mobile networks, local authorities can still refuse proposals that cause unacceptable visual harm. In this case, Erewash Borough Council determined that the balance fell firmly on the side of protecting the character of the area.
The applicant now has the right to appeal to the national Planning Inspectorate.